Written By Matt ‘The Golden Child’ Lebo
2011 (and not the full season) has graced us with some magnificent soccer, horrible defeats, hopeful transfers, unfortunate injuries, and what looks to be a steady progression in talent and awareness for our Croatian players. Even though some players may have had a great season, 2011 helped weed out the great from the good.
The Magician
1. Luka Modrić (Tottenham Hotspur)
The bread and butter of the Croatian National Team and Tottenham Hotspur, Luka Modrić is still growing into his role as one of the best players Croatia has produced, as well as one of the best midfielders in Europe. Looking at his stat sheet, with only three goals and two assists, it raises many questions about his greatness, but it’s the intangible things that he does on the field that convince people why he is one of the top midfielders in the world. His passing, vision, and ability to control the flow of play make him a needed and wanted player by top flight teams in Europe.
Even though he is #1 on our list, he has shown signs of weakness in games with the national team as well as Tottenham. Teams have shown that a strong physical approach and ‘swarm mentality’ have affected Modrić’s game negatively. At a club level, we have seen his role in the midfield change from strictly attacking, to a more all around game. He’s worked hard at improving his defensive abilities, while still being able to perform effectively on offense. Even though he’s had a few setbacks with offensive accolades, we’ve seen his all around performance improve steadily. His passion, work ethic, and value to both teams is what sets him apart, and makes him the top choice.
Jermaine Jenas on Modrić
Luka Modrić Highlight Film
Jelavić takes Scotland by storm
2. Nikica Jelavić (Rangers)
Many of you would argue that Nikica has yet to prove himself to Prva Generacija. After a superb career as an offensive power in Austria, Nikica decided to take his talents to Scotland. After an injury set Jelavić back in the beginning of the season, he made sure to let the rest of the world know what he was all about in 2011. Since his comeback in the middle of January, Nikica has netted 14 goals in 17 appearances, none more important than the game winning goal against rivals Celtic. Along with the 14 goals, Nikica helped propel his team to another SPL title, as well as become the fan favorite at Ibrox stadium.
Even though he is an offensive powerhouse, Nikica has yet to prove himself at a top flight club in Europe. His lack of production for the national team has also brought many questions from his critics. Even with this criticism, Jelavić had a couple things going for him that will help to silence his critics. For one, his lack of quality starts for the national side instill the fact that the best is yet to come from this 25 year-old. Also, his impressive performance in the SPL has brought about rumors of a transfer to top English squad Manchester United. His stock is quickly on the rise, and his strength, acrobatics, and powerful scoring ability is what makes Jelavić Croatia’s #2 for 2011.
Rangers Hero
Rakitić takes his talents to La Liga
3. Ivan Rakitić (Sevilla)
Rated #10 in Top 10 transfers of the year on Goal.com, Ivan has shown that a slow start doesn’t translate into a terrible finish. After an abysmal end to his time at Schalke, it seemed like things were going to keep going downhill, as Rakitić experienced four losses and an own goal at his new club. But this brief spell of dreadful play transformed into brilliance as Rakitić became an important part of the Sevilla squad. With a 0-0 draw looming against bottom of the table opponent Hercules, Rakitić struck with a 78th minute game winning goal. Since that goal, Raki has gone on to score four more goals which either put his team in the lead, tied the game, or won it all. The wondrous form that we used to see at Schalke was coming back to life in Sevilla, while he helps keep them in the top four in La Liga.
For me, the negatives for Rakitić aren’t many. At times, it seems that he loses focus in the midfield for both his club and country. His poor performance and lack of physicality were evident in the beginning of the season for his club, but he’s bounced back since then. His stock has also dropped due his recent injury, that has placed him on the sidelines to end the season. Even though he lacks a bulky stat sheet and large number of appearances for Sevilla, he helped keep his club in the race for a top five finish and announced his presence in La Liga. Rakitić has also started in the last five wins for the national side, which further solidifies his spot at #3.
Rakitić GOOOOOOOOOL
Lovren us a staple in the Lyon defense
4. Dejan Lovren (Lyon)
TGC!? What’s wrong with you!? Don’t worry, I’m not expecting this pick to be a favorite among any of CSR nation. I understand many of you are adjusting your glasses or computer screens to see if you are looking at this right. Well get used to it, because I’m pretty positive we’re going to be seeing and hearing a lot more of this kid for all the right reasons. Out of 12 starts, Lyon has only lost twice with Dejan receiving an average match rating of 6.0, which is good for a defender. His recent performances this month have shown definite improvement and even earned him a ‘man of the match’ award from Goal.com. Let me remind you that this kid is only 21, and the only real problem he’s had were against Real Madrid.
Even though Marcelo ‘did him dirty’, he definitely showed that he was able to hang with the big boys throughout many stages of the match and Champions League. With Lovren at the #4 spot, he definitely has room to grow. His last game showed Prva Generacija that complete maturity and mental toughness have yet to fully develop for the youngster. Along with current mental lapses, which we see in many of our players, he’s still got some work to do on defense. Lovren needs to improve his pace and ability to stick with more technically challenged players. Even though he needs work, his youth and ability to grow is a blessing in disguise for Lovren; and the future of our backline. Since coming to Ligue 1, Lovren has proven that he can excel in a competitive European league by helping his team to a top 3 finish while earning caps for the national team. I’m predicting a bright future for Lovren and expecting him to translate his success and growth from club level to the national level.
LOVREN ON LYON TRANSFER
Die Wunderkind!
5. Ivan Perišić (Club Brugge)
Finally, the last spot goes to Ivan Perišić. He’s been an essential cog for Club Brugge, scoring a total of seven goals, with a number of assists in a 13-game stretch. At the age of 22, his highlight reel is something to admire. His stat line may seem pretty good, but really doesn’t do justice to how dangerous and skillful he is. He’s young, he can finish, and his value has skyrocketed, as top Bundesliga club, Borussia Dortmund, have already picked up the Croatian kid for next season. He topped out in Belgium winning the scoring title and Belgian Player of the Year awards this season. Let’s see what he can do in the Bundesliga.
Just like Lovren, his maturity and talent give him room to grow. He’s technically sound on the ball, but his decision making and passing ability leave something more to be desired. On a national level, I believe more opportunities on the pitch will provide Perišić with confidence, as well as humble his cocky attitude as he goes against tougher competition. With a move to the Bundesliga, we are going to be seeing and talking about this kid for a long time to come.
I know that the Lakić snub may be a bit of a surprise to Prva Generacija, but 2011 has not been as fruitful as 2010, and the five players above have outshined him this year. I tried to do as much research as possible so I could come to you guys with what I thought were the best #5, and I believe that these five showed the best performance and promise this year. I’m working on stat sheets that I can update each week to make write-ups like these more accurate and informative. Constructive criticism and feedback is definitely welcome. Enjoy!
Better late than never I guess. For some reason, this article passed me by.
@Goldenchild,
Well done sir. Well written, informative and entertaining. I like how you ended it with "constructive criticism and feedback is definitely welcome."
Here is my order:
1) Luka Modric
a. our best player hands down
b. the only croatian player guaranteed a starting spot
c. played in arguably the best league in the world, and champions league quarters.
I dont think that #1 is debatable. Also, Tottenham supposedly rejecting a 3o million pound offer from ManU shows his value.
2) Dario Srna
Even though Im not a huge fan, Dario captained Shakhtar to the champions league quarters losing to one of the best teams in the history of the game: Barcelona.
3) Ivan Rakitic
It takes players months to get accustomed to a new league, but it took Ivan a week to get going in Spain after a mid-season transfer from Schalke. Ivan helped Sevilla qualify for the Europa League and hopefully, champions league next season.
4) Nikica Jelavic
A player of the year for Rangers. Scored some memorable goals in 2011. However, the SPL is terrible. Even the "old firm" is not what it used to be. Also, Nikica hasn't shown anything for Croatia. Jelavic will not receive any credit until he transfers to a top 4 league.
5) Srdjan Lakic
Lakic had a great season leading up to the "picture scandal" at Wolfsburg. The team turned on him. The owner turned on him. The fans turned on him. This led to an 8 goal-less drought to start 2011. However, 16 goals in 30 games in my opinion the most competitive big 4 league in the world is a remarkable achievement.
I left out Perisic because the Belgium league has three decent teams and the rest of the league is a bunch of HNL type teams. Perisic is our future and will one day lead Croatia. His time will come.
Lovren had a good year with Lyon. However, made some silly mistakes from time to time against quality opposition. Would be nice to see him at Liverpool.
@Allen,
Yes, I did say that Vida is or will be better than Lovren. Vida desperately needs a loan move to save his career. No way he gets any playing time at Bayer next year.
The famous goal Modric scored against Chelsea a couple years back. I get annoyed when only the pass (from Lenin) and the finish are shown. You need to show apprx the 2 minutes that led up to the goal – Modric was all over the field – he controlled the entire ebb and flow of the battle field and then personally delivered the hammer blow. Did no one else notice it? Cuz I never see a full highlight anywhere.
One more to go for Dirk and the boys!
Whaddya figure?
Srna a definite snub. If you guys have any other ideas/problems, bring em up. I would love to hear why are why not you think certain guys deserve/don't deserve to be here.
Andrej: I think Magath will shape Mandzukic up, he disciplined Rakitic pretty well at Schalke when he was a "party boy"
sorry i post like 5 times instead of 1 huge chunk as it seems easier to read.
Mandza…dreadful till the final 8 matches…I am not a fan but I like the effort. He is still above Lakic for me as he is young and has far more potential to become a better player. I would love to see his play continue as he was playing great at the end of the season but who knows. He is technically gifted and he has lots of pace…i just dislike his attitude but maybe he will mature…
Vida is a good player who made a wrong move. He should have stayed in HNL or made a move where he would see playing time. Maybe he got the paycheck he couldn't resist from Bayer(can't imagine anything crazy maybe better than what he could get elsewhere) or whatever it is but right now his career is put on hold. Loan out move anywhere would be best option for him this summer. Corluka, Vrsaljko, Vida…all future RB for us maybe Vida or Vrsaljo end up at RM for club or NT too.
Perisic and Jelavic were both deserving regardless of the league they play in. Jelavic was a major factor if not the most important reason Rangers won the Cup and the League. Perisic was leading scorer in Belgium both have arguments for being top 5 and both were far more consistent than Lakic who I don't know would even make a top 10….Jelavic maybe wasn't 2nd best but it can be up for debate.
The only clear cut I see is Modric as number 1.
Srna? Lets just say I may not be his biggest fan at RB but the guy has done it for the club for whatever reason and he does well there. Voted into CL team of the year but not Croatia top 5?! Very questionable to say the very least! Like Ziva said at least top 3 if not 2nd….
Rakitic had a great season made a great switch to Seville and played very well in La Liga without knowing the language or anything he came in and did great.
hmmmm….outside of Modric, and even that is debateable, Srna's play at the club level was better than any other cro player.
Enjoy
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WwRNyZTwOM
The reason Jelavic is up there, is based on what he did for his clubs/numbers alone. I find it difficult not to even think about putting him in the top 5. Sure he hasn't done anything for the NT, but his club performance alone is something to brag about.
@ziva
Fair enough. I looked at Srna for a brief period of time, but didn't think he should be added. But yah it's a def possibility.
@mandzukic fanboys
Yes, he's had a good close out, and he's scored a goal for Croatia. But The beginning of 2011 wasn't great for him, and there is no way I could do it.
Srna has to be in the top 3 at the very least….
He was voted on to the all-Champions League team for this season.
Good list. I would have to agree with the 5!!
Jerseycro…can just judge jelavic on NT..you would onyl be judging him on 4 games. Doesnt make sense.
Srna would be 6th just because of the great run in the champions leauge.
I agree with not having Lakic up there.
I love that Lovren is in the top 5!! Very well deserved!
Good job with the list!
Yeah I remember even the great Denis S said that Vida is better than Lovern. It's cool we all make mistakes, but it's amazing how Vida has fallen.
As for Srna, I don't buy it. His performances against Arsenal was pretty poor and I just think with the fans that watch every Croatia game has a bitter taste about Srna. The people that don't follow the team that much love Srna and praise him, but it's not. I like this top five list, it's pretty solid. I like how Rakitic was put on there because he is such a difference maker. I plan on seeing Kranjcar on that list next year.
vida should not move to levekusen in the first place…look at other players who have moved there..vranjes babic tadic..all are flops and could not meet the mark in that club…vida should move to dinamo or hadjuk first and try to develop first…rather than not making the bench at neverkusen..
anyway, where is srna? i understand he did not perform well in national team to warrant a place in top 5…but surely his club and champions league is good enough? he has been making the team of the wk in CL…
vida should not move to levekusen in the first place…look at other players who have moved there..vranjes babic tadic..all are flops and could not meet the mark in that club…vida should move to dinamo or hadjuk first and try to develop first…rather than not making the bench at neverkusen..
anyway, where is srna? i understand he did not perform well in national team to warrant a place in top 5…but surely his club and champions league is good enough? he has been making the team of the wk in CL…
The fact Jelavic is in the top 5 is a big problem, I usually don't care too much about club form but he has shown nothing with the NT
Lovren is a good defender but he still needs some seasoning. My biggest concern with him is he often makes these crazy sliding challenges. I think he is only 21-22 so some of you need to give him a couple more years. I remember some here tried to claim Vida was the better talent (maybe the anti-Dinamo bandwagon?)…Lovren is playing in the CL while Vida is getting drunk hitting kids and possibily transfering to Austria or even the HNL
Rakitic had a great season at Sevilla, he really adapted to La Liga quickly and hopefully he recovers from his injury and returns to good form